I tried Omarchy A Convenient Start but I Prefer Arch from Scratch

As someone who enjoys the flexibility and control that Arch Linux offers, I decided to give Omarchy a try. Omarchy is an opinionated Arch-based distribution that comes pre-configured with Hyprland and a curated set of applications and dotfiles. The goal is to provide a working setup out of the box, allowing users to get started quickly without the need for extensive configuration.

The Good

• Quick Setup: Omarchy’s installer is straightforward, and within 15 minutes, I had a functional system. This is particularly appealing for those who want to avoid the complexities of manual Arch installation.

• Hyprland Experience: The integration of Hyprland as the window manager offers a modern and efficient tiling experience. Workspace switching is smooth, and the overall UI feels clean and responsive.

• Centralized Configuration: Omarchy provides centralized scripts for installing applications and managing settings, which can be convenient for users who prefer a unified approach. The included manual is also a helpful resource for customization.

The Not Good

• Bloat: Omarchy comes with a plethora of pre-installed applications, many of which I didn’t find useful. This unnecessary bloat can consume system resources and clutter the environment. Some users have expressed similar concerns, noting that the setup includes applications like Zoom and other tools that may not be essential for everyone.

• Opinionated Design: The distribution’s design choices, such as the single-user, passwordless login setup, reflect a specific vision that may not align with every user’s preferences. For instance, the lack of a traditional login screen and reliance on the LUKS decryption password prompt can be jarring for those accustomed to more conventional setups.

• Security Concerns: Omarchy utilizes the chaotic-aur repository, which consists of prebuilt AUR packages. This approach can pose security risks, as it limits the ability to audit the PKGBUILD files, potentially introducing vulnerabilities into the system.

• Customization Challenges: While Omarchy is intended to be easily customizable, some users have reported difficulties in adapting the system to their needs. The pre-configured settings and applications can make it challenging to implement personal preferences without delving into the underlying configurations.

Why I Prefer Installing Arch from Scratch

While Omarchy offers a convenient starting point, I find that installing Arch Linux from scratch provides a more tailored and satisfying experience. The manual installation process allows for a deeper understanding of the system’s components and greater control over the configuration. This approach aligns more closely with the Arch philosophy of simplicity and user-centric customization.

Omarchy serves as a useful introduction to Arch Linux for those seeking a ready-made setup. However, for users who value minimalism, transparency, and full control over their environment, installing Arch from scratch remains the preferred choice. It offers a more personalized and secure computing experience, aligning with the core principles that make Arch Linux appealing to many.